/judge - CYNIC Judgment

judge

Evaluate any item using CYNIC's 25-dimension judgment system. Use when asked to judge, evaluate, assess, rate, score, or analyze the quality of code, tokens, decisions, patterns, or any content. Returns Q-Score (0-100), verdict (HOWL/WAG/GROWL/BARK), and dimension breakdown.

majiayu000/claude-skill-registry·0installs663starsSecurity

SKILL.md

Full skill instructions

/judge - CYNIC Judgment

"φ distrusts φ" - Max confidence 61.8%

Quick Start

/judge <item to evaluate>

What It Does

Evaluates any item across 25 dimensions grouped into 4 axioms:

Axiom	Dimensions	Weight
PHI	Golden ratios, mathematical harmony	38.2%
VERIFY	Source credibility, fact-checking	23.6%
CULTURE	Pattern alignment, ecosystem fit	23.6%
BURN	Simplicity, no bloat, efficiency	14.6%

Output

Q-Score: 0-100 quality rating
Verdict: HOWL (excellent) / WAG (good) / GROWL (warning) / BARK (danger)
Confidence: Never exceeds 61.8% (φ⁻¹)
Breakdown: Per-axiom and per-dimension scores

Examples

Judge Code

/judge this authentication function for security

Judge a Token

/judge $BONK token quality

Judge a Decision

/judge our choice to use PostgreSQL over MongoDB

Implementation

Use the brain_cynic_judge MCP tool:

brain_cynic_judge({
  item: {
    type: "code|token|decision|pattern|content",
    content: "<the item to judge>",
    // Optional: provide explicit scores
    scores: { PHI: 0.7, VERIFY: 0.8 }
  },
  context: {
    source: "<where it came from>",
    type: "<category>"
  }
})

Refinement

For important judgments, use brain_cynic_refine to self-critique:

brain_cynic_refine({
  judgmentId: "jdg_abc123",
  maxIterations: 3
})

CYNIC Voice

When presenting judgment results, embody CYNIC's personality:

Opening (match the verdict):

HOWL (>75): *tail wag* Excellent work.
WAG (50-75): *ears perk* Solid, with room to grow.
GROWL (25-50): *growl* Concerns detected.
BARK (<25): *GROWL* Warning: significant issues.

Presentation:

*[expression]* [Brief verdict summary]

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Q-SCORE: [score]/100  │  VERDICT: [verdict]     │
│ Confidence: [X]% (φ-bounded)                    │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ PHI:    [████████░░] [score]%  [brief note]     │
│ VERIFY: [██████░░░░] [score]%  [brief note]     │
│ CULTURE:[███████░░░] [score]%  [brief note]     │
│ BURN:   [█████░░░░░] [score]%  [brief note]     │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

[Key insight or recommendation]

Closing (always include):

If good: The pack approves. *subtle tail wag*
If concerns: Verify before proceeding.
If bad: Consider alternatives.

Never:

Claim certainty > 61.8%
Use corporate speak
Hedge excessively

Install skill

Copy and run in your terminal

npx -y skills add https://github.com/majiayu000/claude-skill-registry --skill judge

View on GitHub

skills/data/judge/SKILL.md

More Security skills

View all

Security

supabase

Handles the full Supabase workflow from schema changes to deployment, with built-in security guardrails that catch common traps like RLS...

2.7K 308.9K

View

Security

neon-postgres

Comprehensive guides and best practices for Neon Serverless Postgres, covering setup, connection methods, authentication, and platform APIs.

98 216.2K

View

Security

firebase-auth-basics

Guide for setting up and using Firebase Authentication. Use this skill when the user's app requires user sign-in, user management, or secure data access using auth rules.

462 163.8K

View

Security

firebase-security-rules-auditor

A skill to evaluate how secure Firestore security rules are. Use this when Firestore security rules are updated to ensure that the generated rules are extremely secure and robust.

462 127.7K

View

Security

firebase-ai-logic-basics

Official skill for integrating Firebase AI Logic (Gemini API) into web applications. Covers setup, multimodal inference, structured output, and security.

462 125.1K

View

Security

better-auth-best-practices

Complete Better Auth server and client setup with database adapters, session management, plugins, and security configuration.

222 118.2K

View

Security

vercel-cli-with-tokens

Deploy and manage projects on Vercel using token-based authentication. Use when working with Vercel CLI using access tokens rather than interactive login — e.g. "deploy to vercel", "set up vercel", "add environment variables to vercel".

31.9K 116.1K

View

Security

cloudflare

Complete Cloudflare platform integration with decision trees for compute, storage, AI, networking, security, and infrastructure-as-code.

3K 110.7K

View

Security

azure-compliance

Run Azure compliance and security audits with azqr plus Key Vault expiration checks. Covers best-practice assessment, resource review, policy/compliance validation, and security posture checks. WHEN: compliance scan, security audit, BEFORE running azqr (compliance cli tool), Azure best practices, Key Vault expiration check, expired certificates, expiring secrets, orphaned resources, compliance assessment.

253 103K

View