Hacker News Post Analysis

Hacker News Post Analysis

Analyze Hacker News posts and their discussions to generate structured reports covering both linked content and community insights.

When to Use

Activate this skill when the user:

• Mentions "Hacker News", "HN", "Y Combinator news"
• Provides a news.ycombinator.com URL
• Asks about a HN discussion or comments
• Mentions "Show HN", "Ask HN", or "Launch HN"
• Wants to understand tech community sentiment on a topic

Instructions

1. Parse the HN URL:
   • Accept news.ycombinator.com/​item?id=XXXXX format
   • Extract item ID
2. Fetch the HN post using WebFetch:
   • Get post title, link, points, author
   • Get top comments (aim for 20-30 top comments)
3. If post links to content: Also fetch linked article
4. If fetching fails:
   • Inform user of issue
   • Suggest checking URL format
   • Stop here
5. Read the analysis prompt from prompts/​hn.md
6. Extract metadata:
   • Title, author, points
   • Post type (Show HN, Ask HN, etc.)
   • Comment count
7. Generate analysis covering both content AND discussion
8. Create output directory reports/​hackernews/ if needed
9. Save the report to reports/​hackernews/​YYYY-MM-DD_sanitized-title.md
10. Update the activity log at logs/​YYYY-MM-DD.md:
    • Add entry under "## HN Discussions" section
    • Format: - [Title](../​reports/​hackernews/​filename.md) - HH:MM
11. Confirm to user what was saved

Report Format

# [Post Title]

**Source**: [HN URL]
**Linked Content**: [Original URL if any]
**Points**: [Score]
**Comments**: [Count]
**Date**: YYYY-MM-DD
**Type**: Hacker News Discussion

---

[Analysis content following prompts/​hn.md structure]

---

## My Notes

[Empty space for user notes]

Error Handling

• If URL format wrong: Suggest correct format
• If post deleted: Inform user
• If comments fail: Analyze post only
• If prompts/​hn.md missing: Use prompts/​default.md

Related

• Slash command: /​hn <url>
• Prompt file: prompts/​hn.md
• Output: reports/​hackernews/