Functions Over Classes: fn(args, deps)

Functions Over Classes: fn(args, deps)

Core Pattern

All business logic functions MUST follow this signature:

fn(args, deps)

• args: Per-call input data (varies each invocation)
• deps: Long-lived collaborators (injected infrastructure)

Why Two Parameters (Not One Object)

args and deps have different lifetimes:

• args are per-call data
• deps are long-lived collaborators

Keeping them separate makes dependency bloat visible and composition easier.

Required Behaviors

1. Per-Function Dependency Types

ALWAYS declare explicit deps types for each function:

// CORRECT
type GetUserDeps = {
  db: Database;
  logger: Logger;
};

async function getUser(
  args: { userId: string },
  deps: GetUserDeps
): Promise<User | null> {
  deps.logger.info(`Getting user ${args.userId}`);
  return deps.db.findUser(args.userId);
}

// WRONG - God object with all deps
async function getUser(
  args: { userId: string },
  deps: AllServiceDeps  // Contains mailer, cache, metrics that getUser doesn't use
): Promise<User | null>

2. No Classes for Business Logic

Classes become problematic when:

• 10+ methods accumulate over time
• Private helpers create implicit coupling via this
• Constructor grows to satisfy every method's needs

// WRONG
class UserService {
  constructor(
    private db: Database,
    private logger: Logger,
    private mailer: Mailer,  // only createUser needs this
    private cache: Cache,     // only someOtherMethod needs this
  ) {}
}

// CORRECT
type GetUserDeps = { db: Database; logger: Logger };
type CreateUserDeps = { db: Database; logger: Logger; mailer: Mailer };

3. Factory at the Boundary (Composition Root)

Wire deps ONCE at the boundary, not at every call site:

// user-service/​index.ts
export function createUserService({ deps }: { deps: UserServiceDeps }) {
  return {
    getUser: ({ userId }: { userId: string }) =>
      getUser({ userId }, deps),
    createUser: ({ name, email }: { name: string; email: string }) =>
      createUser({ name, email }, deps),
  };
}

// main.ts (Composition Root)
const deps = { db, logger, mailer };
const userService = createUserService({ deps });

// Handlers stay clean
await userService.getUser({ userId: '123' });

4. Grouping Related Functions

When you have many related functions (5+), choose one approach per module:

Approach 1: Inject Individually (default)

Use when most consumers only need 1–2 functions:

// user-functions.ts
export async function getUser(args: { userId: string }, deps: GetUserDeps) { ... }
export async function createUser(args: { name: string; email: string }, deps: CreateUserDeps) { ... }

export type GetUserFn = typeof getUser;
export type CreateUserFn = typeof createUser;

// notification-handler.ts — only needs sendWelcomeEmail
export type NotificationHandlerDeps = {
  sendWelcomeEmail: SendWelcomeEmailFn;
  // doesn't need getUser or createUser
};

Approach 2: Inject as Grouped Object (when they travel together)

Use when functions form a cohesive module and consumers inject the same set:

// user-functions.ts
export const userFns = {
  getUser,
  createUser,
  updateUser,
  deleteUser,
  sendWelcomeEmail,
} as const;

export type UserFns = typeof userFns;

// user-router.ts — needs most user functions
export type UserRouterDeps = {
  userFns: UserFns;
};

Rule of thumb: Default to injecting individually. Group only when functions genuinely travel together. If grouping feels like a "god object", split it.

5. Inject Only What You'll Mock

Only inject things that hit network, disk, or clock. Import pure utilities directly:

// WRONG - Over-injecting
function createUser(args, deps: { db, logger, slugify, randomUUID }) { }

// CORRECT - Only inject what you'll mock
import { slugify } from 'slugify';
import { randomUUID } from 'crypto';
function createUser(args, deps: { db, logger }) { }

6. Type-Only Imports for Interfaces

Use import type to prevent runtime coupling:

// CORRECT
import type { Mailer } from '../​infra/​mailer';

// WRONG - Runtime import creates coupling
import { mailer } from '../​infra/​mailer';

Testing Pattern

import { describe, it, expect } from 'vitest';
import { mock } from 'vitest-mock-extended';
import { getUser, type GetUserDeps } from './​get-user';

it('returns user when found', async () => {
  const mockUser = { id: '123', name: 'Alice', email: '[email protected]' };

  const deps = mock<GetUserDeps>();
  deps.db.findUser.mockResolvedValue(mockUser);

  const result = await getUser({ userId: '123' }, deps);
  expect(result).toEqual(mockUser);
});

Migration Strategy (Strangler Fig)

Phase 1: Add deps with defaults (backward compatible)

import { mailer as _mailer, type Mailer } from '../​infra/​mailer';

const defaultDeps: SendEmailDeps = { mailer: _mailer };

export async function sendEmail(
  recipient: User,
  sender: User,
  deps: SendEmailDeps = defaultDeps  // Default for existing callers
) { ... }

Phase 2: Remove defaults (explicit DI required)

import type { Mailer } from '../​infra/​mailer';

export async function sendEmail(
  recipient: User,
  sender: User,
  deps: SendEmailDeps  // No default - must inject
) { ... }

Phase 3 (Optional): Use object parameters

export async function sendEmail(
  args: { recipient: User; sender: User },
  deps: SendEmailDeps
) { ... }

When Classes ARE Acceptable

Classes are fine for:

Classes are NOT OK for:

• Business logic (use functions)
• Anything that will grow beyond 3-4 methods
• When you find yourself adding private helpers

Framework Integration (NestJS)

Use classes as thin wrappers, keep logic in pure functions:

// Pure function - your actual logic
async function createUser(
  args: CreateUserInput,
  deps: { db: Database; logger: Logger }
): Promise<Result<User, 'EMAIL_EXISTS' | 'DB_ERROR'>> {
  // Business logic here
}

// NestJS wrapper - thin delegation layer
@Injectable()
export class UserService {
  constructor(private db: Database, private logger: Logger) {}

  async createUser(args: CreateUserInput) {
    return createUser(args, { db: this.db, logger: this.logger });
  }
}

Performance Considerations

Critics sometimes worry that creating many small objects (args objects, deps bags, factory functions) increases garbage collection pressure.

The reality: Modern V8 engines (Orinoco) use generational garbage collection. Objects that die young—like the temporary objects created during request handling—are reclaimed almost instantly. V8 is extremely efficient at this.

For I/​O-bound web applications:

The database query is 10,000-500,000x slower than object allocation. The architectural clarity and type safety of the fn(args, deps) pattern far outweigh any micro-overhead.

When to worry about allocation:

• Tight loops processing millions of items
• Real-time systems with hard latency requirements
• Memory-constrained embedded environments

For typical web services, don't optimize for GC. Optimize for correctness, testability, and maintainability.

Enforcement

Enable in tsconfig.json:

{
  "compilerOptions": {
    "verbatimModuleSyntax": true
  }
}

ESLint rule to prevent infra imports:

"no-restricted-imports": ["error", {
  patterns: [{
    group: ["**/​infra/​**"],
    message: "Domain code must not import from infra. Inject dependencies instead."
  }]
}]