Agent Reviewer (Story)

Paths: File paths (shared/, references/, ../​ln-*) are relative to skills repo root. If not found at CWD, locate this SKILL.md directory and go up one level for repo root.

Agent Reviewer (Story)

Runs parallel external agent reviews on validated Story and Tasks, critically verifies suggestions, returns editorial improvements.

Purpose & Scope

• Worker in ln-310 validation pipeline (invoked in Phase 5)
• Run codex-review + gemini-review as background tasks in parallel
• Process results as they arrive (first-finished agent processed immediately)
• Critically verify each suggestion; debate with agent if Claude disagrees
• Return filtered, deduplicated, verified suggestions for Story/​Tasks improvement
• Health check + prompt execution in single invocation

When to Use

• Invoked by ln-310-story-validator Phase 5 (Agent Review)
• After Phase 4 auto-fixes applied (Penalty Points reduced; Before/​After per ln-310)
• Story and Tasks are in their final form before approval

Parameters

Inputs

Resolution: Story Resolution Chain. Status filter: Backlog

Workflow

MANDATORY READ: Load shared/​references/​input_resolution_pattern.md, shared/​references/​tools_config_guide.md, shared/​references/​storage_mode_detection.md, shared/​references/​agent_review_workflow.md, and shared/​references/​agent_delegation_pattern.md.

Phase 0: Resolve Inputs & Tools Config

1. Resolve storyId (per input_resolution_pattern.md):

   • IF args provided → use args
   • ELSE IF git branch matches feature/​{id}-* → extract id
   • ELSE IF kanban has exactly 1 Story in [Backlog] → suggest
   • ELSE → AskUserQuestion: show Stories from kanban filtered by [Backlog]

2. Extract: task_provider from docs/​tools_config.md (per tools_config_guide.md).

Unique Steps (before shared workflow)

1. Health check: per shared workflow, filter by skill_group = 311.

2. Get references:

   • IF task_provider = linear: get_issue(storyId) → extract URL + identifier. list_issues(filter: {parent: {id: storyId}}) → extract child Task URLs/​identifiers.
   • IF task_provider = file: Read story.md → extract path. Glob("docs/​tasks/​epics/​*/​stories/​*/​tasks/​*.md") → extract child Task file paths.

3. Ensure .agent-review/: per shared workflow.

4. Build prompt: Read template shared/​agents/​prompt_templates/​story_review.md.

   • Replace {story_ref} with - Linear: {url} or - File: {path}
   • Replace {task_refs} with bullet list: - {identifier}: {url_or_path} per task
   • Save to .agent-review/​{identifier}_storyreview_prompt.md (single shared file -- both agents read the same prompt)

Shared Workflow Steps

5-8) Load Review Memory, Run agents, Critical Verification + Debate, Aggregate + Return: per shared workflow.

• {review_type} = "Story/​Tasks" (for challenge template)

1. Save Review Summary: per shared workflow "Step: Save Review Summary".

Output Format

verdict: STORY_ACCEPTABLE | SUGGESTIONS | SKIPPED
suggestions:
  - area: "security | performance | architecture | feasibility | best_practices | risk_analysis"
    issue: "What is wrong or could be improved"
    suggestion: "Specific change to Story or Tasks"
    confidence: 95
    impact_percent: 15
    source: "codex-review"
    resolution: "accepted | accepted_after_debate | accepted_after_followup | rejected"

Agent stats and debate log per shared workflow output schema.

Fallback Rules

Per shared workflow, plus:

Verdict Escalation

• No escalation. Suggestions are editorial only -- they modify Story/​Tasks text.
• Parent skill (ln-310) Gate verdict remains unchanged by agent suggestions.

Critical Rules (additional)

• MANDATORY INVOCATION: Parent skills MUST invoke this skill. Returns SKIPPED gracefully if agents unavailable. Parent must NOT pre-check and skip.

Reference Files

• Tools config: shared/​references/​tools_config_guide.md
• Storage mode operations: shared/​references/​storage_mode_detection.md
• Shared workflow: shared/​references/​agent_review_workflow.md
• Agent delegation pattern: shared/​references/​agent_delegation_pattern.md
• Prompt template (review): shared/​agents/​prompt_templates/​story_review.md
• Challenge schema: shared/​agents/​schemas/​challenge_review_schema.json

---

Version: 2.0.0 Last Updated: 2026-02-11